To succeed as a dividend growth investor you must identify and purchase stocks with sustainable dividend growth. Put another way, targeted companies must be both capable and willing to grow their dividends. Obviously, we can not look into the future and see who will and will not perform. However, there are critical bits of information that we can evaluate today that often foreshadow the company’s future behavior. Here are some of the more relevant ones:
Years Of Consecutive Dividend Increases
Inertia is powerful force. Once a company has established a track record of growing its dividend over the decades and developed a shareholder base that expects higher dividends each year, it becomes increasing difficult for management to cut or fail to raise their dividend. No CEO of this type of company wants a dividend cut to occur on his or her watch. There are precious few Dividend Aristocrats remaining and those left enjoy their elite status.
Strong Financial Condition
Dividends are paid with cash, not earnings. The distinction is subtle, but very real. In its pursuit of theoretical perfection, the accounting profession has adulterated the financial statements to the point that it has become very difficult for non-accountants to interpret them. For example, 2009 was a tough year for Nucor (NUE). Its consolidated statement of earnings showed a loss of $237 million, down from 2008′s earnings of $1.8 billion. This decrease in earnings of $2 billion looks devastating until you consider flip over to the consolidated statements of cash flows and realize NUE’s management ran the business to maximize cash generation. The $2 billion decrease in earnings only equated to $688 million dollar decrease in free cash flow and while earnings were negative, free cash flow remained positive at $792 million, more than enough to cover the $443 million dividend payments.
Consider another example. In 2009 Eli Lilly’s (LLY) net earnings improved $6.4 billion, but its free cash flow decreased $2.8 billion. This oddity was primarily the result of how in-process research and development was accounted for. Here is an excerpt from their 2009 10-k describing the accounting:
Most of these acquisitions included IPR&D, which represented compounds, new indications, or line extensions under development that had not yet achieved regulatory approval for marketing. There are several methods that can be used to determine the estimated fair value of the IPR&D acquired in a business combination. We utilized the “income method”, which applies a probability weighting to the estimated future net cash flows that are derived from projected sales revenues and estimated costs. These projections are based on factors such as relevant market size, patent protection, historical pricing of similar products, and expected industry trends. The estimated future net cash flows are then discounted to the present value using an appropriate discount rate. This analysis is performed for each project independently. Pursuant to the existing rules, these acquired IPR&D intangible assets totaling $4.71 billion and $340.5 million in 2008 and 2007, respectively, were expensed immediately subsequent to the acquisition because the products had no alternative future use. The ongoing expenses with respect to each of these products in development are not material to our total research and development expense currently and are not expected to be material to our total research and development expense on an annual basis in the future.
In effect LLY realized a $4.7 billion dollar non-cash charge in 2008, which was an add-back to operating cash flow. There was no similar charge in 2009, thus the substantial increase in earnings.
When evaluating a company’s financial you must also consider competing uses for the free cash flow generated. Many companies generate significant free cash flow, but often that cash is already spoken for in the form of debt obligations. One of the key metrics I look for when evaluating a company is a debt to total capital ratio of 45% or less.
9 Stocks With a Sustainable Dividend
Using my D4L-Data spreadsheet to screen the 170+ stocks that I follow, I limited my search to stocks with the following characteristics:
- Years of consecutive dividend increases > 30 years
- Yield > 3.0%
- Debt to total capital < 45%
- Free Cash Flow Payout < 60%
Below are several stocks that meet the above criteria:
|Company||Analysis||Yield||Div. Gro.||Debt/Cap.||FCF Pay.|
|Diebold, Inc. (DBD)||–||3.69%||57||34.73%||28.10%|
|Leggett & Platt, (LEG)||Link||4.47%||38||32.48%||29.34%|
|V.F. Corporation (VFC)||–||3.10%||36||23.73%||30.01%|
|RPM International (RPM)||Link||4.11%||37||41.42%||33.46%|
|Northwest Natural (NWN)||-||3.63%||37||9.79%||39.54%|
|Genuine Parts Co. (GPC)||Link||4.04%||54||15.74%||40.59%|
|Johnson & Johnson (JNJ)||Link||3.62%||48||22.33%||41.42%|
|Abbott Laboratories (ABT)||Link||3.62%||38||41.86%||42.99%|
|Automatic Data (ADP)||Link||3.30%||34||0.72%||47.64%|
Bonus: Look For A Favorable Industry
Some industries are more stable than others. When the economy turns down and we are concerned about our job, we may discontinue our pest control or lawn service, but we will likely not stop taking our blood pressure medicine. Non-cyclical industries typically include pharmaceuticals, utilities, defense and certain consumer goods. A company’s ability to grow its dividend is directly related to its ability to grow free cash flow.
Full Disclosure: Long ABT, ADP, GPC, JNJ, LEG, LLY, NUE, NWN. See a list of all my income holdings here.